Average Wisconsin Roof Replacement Cost: Free Price Estimate

The average Wisconsin roof replacement cost varies from $4,345 to $11,401.

Why this wide range? Well, it depends drastically on factors such as the materials you use and the roof size.

So, you can get a better idea of how much your new roof will cost you, work your way through this guide.

Average roof replacement cost Wisconsin guide

To provide you with a comprehensive understanding of the average cost of roof replacement in Wisconsin, we’ll be covering the following factors that affect the cost:

  • Material
  • Roof size & pitch
  • Labor costs
  • Design
  • Installation techniques
  • Location
  • Additional costs

How much does a new roof cost in Wisconsin?

The average Wisconsin new roof cost ranges from $4,345 to $11,401, depending on factors such as the type of roofing material and the roof size. It’s important to note that these costs can vary based on additional factors such as complexity of the roof design and any necessary structural repairs.

Considering the lifespan of roofs, it’s worth mentioning that most roofs can last between 30 to 50 years before requiring replacement. The longevity of a roof can also depend on factors such as the quality of the materials used, the climate conditions in the area, and the regular maintenance and care given to the roof.

Though the cost of replacing a roof may seem daunting, it’s important to see it as an investment in your home’s longevity and value.

A sturdy, high-quality roof not only protects from the elements but also enhances comfort and aesthetic appeal. It can also increase your property’s resale value, making it a good long-term investment.

With this in mind, if you want to get us to quote you for your roof replacement and are in Wisconsin, get in touch with us!

Image of home with word CONTACT overlayed in white

What factors affect Wisconsin roofing prices?

Understanding these variables will equip you with the knowledge to make informed decisions regarding your WI roof replacement project.


The choice of roofing material significantly impacts the overall cost of the project, mainly due to the variable roofing cost per square foot associated with different materials.

Here is a table summarizing the cost of common roofing materials per square foot:

MaterialAverage roof price per sq. ft.
Steel$10 – $21
Aluminum$2.15 – $7
Asphalt shingles$3 – $6
Wood Shingles/Shakes$5 – $12
Clay Tiles$8 – $25
Concrete Tiles$4 – $15
Slate$10 – $30
Synthetic (rubber, plastic, etc.)$9.00 – $12
Built-Up Roofing (BUR)$4.00 – $7.50
Modified Bitumen$4.00 – $7.50

Of course, there are a lot more materials on the market, but these are the most popular options in the roofing industry.

For instance, Madison WI metal roofing can have other variations such as copper, zinc, and lead. Also, please note that the prices mentioned above are just cost estimates and can vary based on other factors which we’ll cover in further sections.

Roof size & pitch

Roofing contractors typically calculate costs per roofing square (100 square feet). Thus, a larger roof will require more material resulting in a higher cost.

For instance, a roof measuring 2,000 square feet will cost less ($6,700 – $13,400) to replace compared to a roof measuring 3,000 square feet ($10,100 – $20,100).

However, the number of roofing squares is not always equivalent to the square footage of your home because roofs are often pitched. Contractors will also factor in the roof’s pitch or slope, which can add to the square footage and increase the overall cost.

For example, a moderately pitched roof could mean 15-20% more square footage than the home’s floor space.

In addition, variations in roof design and complexity (such as the presence of chimneys, skylights, or complex architectural features) can increase the overall size of the roof, hence affecting the replacement cost.

Labor costs

The cost of labor is typically calculated per square (100 square feet) and varies depending on the complexity of the project, the time it takes to complete it, and the contractor’s rates.

Here are some factors that may affect labor costs:

  • Job complexity: Complex roofing designs with steep slopes, multiple corners, or unique architectural features require more time and expertise to replace. These complexities might necessitate special equipment or additional labor hours, thereby increasing the cost.
  • Contractor rates: Different contractors have different rates that are influenced by factors such as their experience, reputation, and overhead costs. It’s always advisable to get multiple estimates and to compare not only the total cost but also to break down the cost of materials, labor, and any additional fees.
  • Removal and disposal of old roofing: The cost of removing and disposing of your current roofing material can be included in the overall labor cost. The cost can vary based on the weight and type of the material being removed.
  • Additional repairs: If your roof has underlying damage or needs structural adjustments before the new roof can be installed, this will increase labor time and costs.

Keep in mind that while it may be tempting to go with the lowest quote, the price should not be the only factor when choosing a contractor. The quality of the work and materials used is equally, if not more, important.

The saying, “You get what you pay for,” often holds in roof replacement projects — it’s crucial to invest in good quality work to avoid higher maintenance or replacement costs down the line.

Contact us today for a free quote for your Wisconsin roof replacement

Image of home with word CONTACT overlayed in white


The more complex the design, the higher the cost tends to be:

  • Style: Common styles, such as gable or hip, are easier and less expensive to replace due to their simplicity. More intricate designs, like mansard or gambrel can be more costly due to the complexity of their structure.
  • Architectural features: Elements such as dormers, valleys, or skylights add complexity to the job, requiring additional time, materials, and technical expertise, which in turn, increase the cost.
  • Number of layers: If your roof has multiple layers of shingles that need to be removed, this will add to the labor time and disposal costs.

It’s important to strike a balance between aesthetics and practical considerations like cost, maintenance, and durability when planning your roof replacement project.

Installation techniques

Below are some common roofing installation techniques and how they may affect your budget:

  • Strip shingles: This is a straightforward process where the old roof shingles are stripped off and new ones are installed. It is a relatively quick process that, depending on the size and complexity of your roof, could be completed within a day or two.
  • Roof over or re-roofing: In this method, new shingles are placed over the existing roof. This method is less time-consuming and thus less expensive because it eliminates the costs associated with removing and disposing of the old roof. However, it may not address underlying issues like leaks or water damage.
  • Tear-off roofing: Involves removing the entire old roof before installing a new one. While this method is more costly and time-consuming as it involves more labor, it allows for the inspection and repair of any underlying damage, ensuring a more durable and longer-lasting roof.
  • Specialized installation techniques: Certain types of roofs, like metal or tile roofs, require specialized installation techniques and expertise. This can increase the overall cost due to the need for specific tools or materials and additional labor time.

Remember, the choice of installation method should be influenced by more than just cost. Consider also the longevity and future maintenance requirements of your roof.

A cheaper installation method may end up costing more in the long run if it results in higher maintenance costs or needs to be replaced sooner.

Local factors

The following Wisconsin-related factors will also play a part:

  • Cost of living: If the cost of living (inflation) is currently high, naturally, the cost of the replacement will be higher (although we try to mitigate this and not pass on the costs as much as possible).
  • Regulations: Local building codes and regulations can require specific types or grades of materials, or particular construction methods.
  • Weather conditions: During the winter months in Wisconsin, high winds and heavy snowfall tend to require more durable roofing materials, while maintaining ventilation for the warmer summer months.
  • Accessibility: For instance, if your home is located in a densely populated urban area where parking is challenging, or if the roof is hard to reach, these factors could increase labor costs.

Additional reading: how long does a roof last in Wisconsin

Additional costs

Aside from the specific roofing costs, be aware of these other potential expenses:

  • Permit fees: In Madison, WI, for example, you will need a building permit to replace your roof.
  • Inspection fees: Framing and final inspections are required in Madison.
  • Warranty: While most new roofs come with a warranty, there can be variations in warranty coverage. Some roofing companies might offer more comprehensive warranties at an additional cost.

Planning for these additional costs ahead of time can help to ensure that you stay within your budget and aren’t surprised by unexpected expenses during your roof replacement project.

Can Prairie Exteriors give a roof replacement estimate near me?

Prairie Exteriors can provide you with an accurate estimate for WI metal roofing or shingle roofing replacement. We are a locally-owned Wisconsin roofing business, covering the entire state, but with a specific focus on the current locations:

MadisonFitchburgSauk City
Sun PrairieMiddletonPortage
DeforestPrairie du Sac

Contact us about our free roof estimates today!

Take the first step towards a durable, weather-resistant, and attractive new roof by reaching out to Prairie Exteriors.

We provide free, transparent, and detailed estimates, taking the guesswork out of your roofing project.

Contact us today to learn more about our services, view our project portfolio, and schedule your free estimate!

Image of home with word CONTACT overlayed in white

Recent Posts
a house in Wisconsin with snow on the roofclose up of a drip edge with water dripping off